Skip to content
Charm Nail Spa

Charm Nail Spa

Power Beyond Expectation

Primary Menu
  • Computer & Technology
  • internet marketing
  • Web Design
  • Technology
  • computer
  • Business
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • Is the Supreme Court Roe v Wade Leak Illegal? The Law Is Unclear
  • computer

Is the Supreme Court Roe v Wade Leak Illegal? The Law Is Unclear

Lisa H. Shelton May 4, 2022 3 minutes read

[ad_1]

“Legal scholarship provides little clarity regarding § 641’s interpretation; only a few scholars have even recognized § 641’s application to information,” reads a Columbia Law Review article about the statute’s use for prosecuting leakers, written by Jessica Lutkenhaus, an attorney focused on criminal defense at the law firm Wilmer Hale. “The circuits disagree about whether § 641 applies to information, and, if it does, what its scope is: What information constitutes a ‘thing of value’?”

Sharing information is arguably fundamentally different from stealing “a thing of value,” Freedom of the Press Foundation’s Timm points out. “You can’t steal a government Jeep or take something tangible or physical from government offices,” Timm says. “But copying something can be construed as different from stealing something. You copy it, and the original thing is still there, and you just leave with papers that didn’t exist before.”

That ambiguity has led different federal courts to come to contradictory conclusions. A Fourth Circuit court, for instance, found in 1991 that a Department of Defense employee who left the DOD for a job at a defense contractor and took information with him was guilty of violating § 641. But a Ninth Circuit court has come to an opposite conclusion, finding in a 1959 case that “intangible” goods are not covered by § 641. That ruling was later applied in 1988 by the same circuit to the case of an information leaker, a naval officer accused of stealing computer punch cards related to secret encryption information. The court confirmed that the information itself was not covered by § 641—though his appeal was thrown out anyway because he’d stolen the physical punch cards that stored it.

Other circuit courts have come to conclusions somewhere in between, with some finding, for instance, that the § 641 does apply to information leaks but noting that this doesn’t extend to those covered by the First Amendment’s protections on free speech and freedom of the press—findings with direct relevance to Politico’s Supreme Court leaker.

Several of the most notable leakers in history have been charged under 18 U.S.C. § 641, too, including Daniel Ellsberg, Chelsea Manning, and Edward Snowden. But the use of that law was overshadowed by their prosecution under the Espionage Act, since all three were accused of leaking classified secrets, and none set a clear precedent. Ellsberg’s charges were dropped due to improper government conduct by the Nixon administration, and Snowden has yet to face trial. Manning was convicted on the 18 U.S.C. § 641 count she faced, but in a military court, not a civilian one.

All of that leaves the legal status of Politico’s leaker—if they are identified—far from certain. But any confident argument that they committed a crime is on equally shaky terrain, argues Timm. And that’s especially true in a case where the leaker appears to have leaked a document directly to the press, with a clear interest in making the information public.

“Even if prosecutors think 18 U.S.C. § 641 applies, I’d have serious First Amendment concerns with broadly applying it to anyone who leaks a government document to the press,” Timm says. “Leaks to the press are as American as apple pie. And, in many cases throughout history, have furthered democracy rather than hindered it.”


More Great WIRED Stories

[ad_2]

Source link

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • About the Author
    • Lisa H. Shelton

About the Author

Lisa H. Shelton

Administrator

Visit Website View All Posts

Post navigation

Previous: Marketing Guide for Logistics Businesses To Fuel Growth
Next: LTHS Awarded For Gender Diversity In Computer Science

Related News

Revolutionize Your Workflow: The Hidden Power of Creative Software Hacks
  • computer

Revolutionize Your Workflow: The Hidden Power of Creative Software Hacks

Lisa H. Shelton September 1, 2026
The Future of Computing: Where AI Meets Human Ingenuity
  • computer

The Future of Computing: Where AI Meets Human Ingenuity

Lisa H. Shelton August 30, 2026
The Hidden Battle Inside Your PC: How Computer Hardware Powers the Digital World
  • computer

The Hidden Battle Inside Your PC: How Computer Hardware Powers the Digital World

Lisa H. Shelton August 28, 2026

Categories

  • Business
  • computer
  • Computer & Technology
  • internet
  • internet marketing
  • Technology
  • Web Design

Archives

Recent Posts

  • How to Choose Guest Posting Sites for Bookkeeping Content
  • How Cybersecurity and Networking Work Together, and How to Make Your Network Secure
  • The Future of Computing: Unlocking the Power of Quantum AI
  • The Future Unplugged: How AI is Redefining Human Creativity
  • Future-Proofing Your Business: Trends Driving the Next Decade

Fiverr

Fiverr Logo   

BL

serpzilla

You may have missed

  • Technology

How to Choose Guest Posting Sites for Bookkeeping Content

Lisa H. Shelton October 30, 2026
How Cybersecurity and Networking Work Together, and How to Make Your Network Secure
  • Technology

How Cybersecurity and Networking Work Together, and How to Make Your Network Secure

Lisa H. Shelton October 30, 2026
The Future of Computing: Unlocking the Power of Quantum AI
  • Computer & Technology

The Future of Computing: Unlocking the Power of Quantum AI

Lisa H. Shelton September 3, 2026
The Future Unplugged: How AI is Redefining Human Creativity
  • Technology

The Future Unplugged: How AI is Redefining Human Creativity

Lisa H. Shelton September 3, 2026
charmnailspa.com | MoreNews by AF themes.

WhatsApp us